Brotherhood Winery Reviews
Reviews
4.9 out of 5 rating
4.9 out of 5 rating
79 Reviews
97% recommend it
Awards
-
![Abigail]()
Abigail B. Sent on 10/21/2023The Most Romantic Venue
Brotherhood was my dream venue. I cannot say enough good things. The winery itself is so beautiful, so romantic, so classic. The stone walls and cast iron chandeliers set the perfect scene for our 100 guest wedding. Eileen, our coordinator, and Trish, from InnCredible Caters (from the on-site restaurant, 1839) were absolutely amazing. They made my wedding PERFECT. They made sure every detail was taken care of. They ushered us around on the day of. They made sure my husband and I got to eat the amazing food from the cocktail hour. Trish even helped me bustle my dress. And Eileen made sure we always had drinks in our hands! The night was perfect thanks to their help. Everyone raved about how beautiful a setting it was. And the list of their preferred vendors was equally amazing. We booked most of our other vendors from their list which just made coordinating everything so effortless. They gave my husband and I special access to the wine cellar so we could take photos. Absolutely stunning! And I highly recommend using InnCredible Caterers! It was just perfect. -
![Taylor]()
Taylor H. Sent on 10/18/2023Absolutely amazing!
Absolutely beautiful venue, exactly what we were looking for. We had 165 people at our wedding and the room felt full, without being overcrowded. The venue was beautiful and my guests were so amazed by the stone and wood. They also could not say enough good things about the food, the bartenders and wait staff who worked so quickly. Even with last minute thunderstorms rolling in at the time of our ceremony, the team did an amazing job of making sure our day was still special. Throughout the entire process Donny and Eileen were always available to answer any questions and were extremely helpful. Brotherhood Winery was the best!! -
-
![Kimberly Carr]()
Kimberly C. Sent on 07/28/2023The perfect wedding venue!
The perfect venue!!!! Guys, I am not being bias. Our wedding day was literally perfect all thanks to brotherhood winery. They really do such an exceptional job taking care of their bride and groom. A huge thank you to the wedding coordinators Trish and Eileen, they are so helpful throughout this stressful process! I am so beyond happy with our wedding day, every single person I spoke to that attended our wedding day was nonstop talking about how much fun they had. They were so pleased with the service, and the food was outstanding. (We used the caterers at their restaurant 1839, def recommend!!!) Not one person said things were just okay, everyone loved it! Thank you times a million brotherhood winery!!!! Your venue is so beyond beautiful. **FYI if you get married here, they allow the bride and groom to take photos in their wine cellar. The photos there come out so rustic and amazing!!!** -
-
![Nicole]()
Nicole K. Sent on 11/03/2022Have your wedding here!!!
Brotherhood Winery is a hidden gem! This venue is stunning and barely needs any decorations to make it look beautiful. The staff is friendly and so easy to work with. Donny was easy to communicate with and honestly an amazing presence to have on our wedding day. He answered all our questions promptly and gave great vendor recommendations that work with the winery often. I HIGHLY recommend having your wedding at Brotherhood!! -
Eryn M. Sent on 10/03/2022
Beautiful wedding venue!
I just got married on 10/1/22 and couldn’t recommend Brotherhood more! The venue was so beautiful and was exactly what we had wanted. We had an outdoor ceremony, cocktail hour on the patio and our reception inside. Donny was great to work with and very responsive!
-
-
Lauren M. Sent on 11/03/2022
An unforgettable wedding
We had our reception at the The Brotherhood Winery. It was gorgeous. I couldn’t imagine getting married anywhere else and I am a Brotherhood Bride for life! The Grand Monarque Hall is simply breathtaking. Being the oldest winery in America speaks for itself as you can’t find that degree of craftsmanship ANYWHERE else. It was everything I could’ve imagined and more. The space worked so well for us, both sides of the family were able to intermix and truly enjoy themselves and the company. We received so many compliments on the Brotherhood throughout as well as after the wedding. I especially enjoyed being able to work with Donny- he was always so accommodating, kind, prompt and responsive. He checked in, followed up and did everything he could to make sure we had everything we needed and more, including finding the perfect place to assemble our neon sign, which I only gave to him 2 days prior to the wedding day! He was so generous to us. Thanks Donny and the Brotherhood Winery for a day/night I’ll never forget -
-
![Brian]()
Brian L. Sent on 06/04/2022Perfect wedding venue.
We’re so happy we got married at Brotherhood Winery.
If you haven’t visited yet, the property is beautiful. We had our ceremony on the lawn, cocktail hour on the patio, and our reception in the Grand Monarque Hall. It’s very picturesque and our wedding photos came out great.
We picked Brotherhood because we loved Grand Monarque Hall’s high vaulted ceilings, beautiful stonework, and overall rustic feel. We were looking for a venue that had a lot of character and charm and the night of our wedding, it did not disappoint. Once the lighting, music, and drinks were added, the hall had a great vibe for our celebration.
We decided to go with Incredible Caterers (the on-premise restaurant) and the food and service was wonderful. Since Incredible and Brotherhood have done many weddings together, the whole process of coordinating and selecting our menu was seamless and easy for us.
I can’t say enough good things about Donny. He was kind and great to work with. The entire year leading up to our wedding day, Donny was quick to respond whenever we had a question. If there was something he was able to do to help make our day better, he did it. He connected us with some great vendors and would even take the initiative to reach out to us if he found something we hadn’t thought of.
Thank you to the Brotherhood staff for a wedding we’ll never forget. -
-
![Valerie]()
Valerie K. Sent on 04/10/2022In love with this venue
The venue is absolutely gorgeous! You do not need much in the way of decor because of how beautiful it is. The stone, wooden beams & rustic feel is incredible. Donny is great to work with. Thank you for hosting our wedding! We love Brotherhood! -
![Gina]()
Gina Sent on 06/19/2022Wonderful and amazing
It was amazing and absolutely wonderful! Everyone was so amazing! -
![Jennifer]()
Jennifer B. Sent on 11/23/2020Don't hesitate - book them today!
I cannot say enough wonderful things about our recent wedding at Brotherhood Winery (11/21). Donny is the absolute best. Planning a wedding during Covid is a nightmare as I'm sure you can imagine, and Donny went out of his way to hold my hand throughout the process and to work with me every time we had to pivot due to the ever changing rules. He was able to work with us to host the wedding of our dreams (with fewer guests per NYS Guidelines of course) that would still be beautiful and safe for our loved ones. Not to mention, the entire grounds are gorgeous and made for amazing photos. We used Inn Credible Caterer's, and they were wonderful as well. Everyone is still raving about the food. Pay extra for the lamb chop appetizers - everyone can't say enough about them. Totally worth it! All in all, don't think twice about booking your wedding here! -
![Francesca]()
Francesca Sent on 10/30/2019Amazing wedding day at the Brotherhood!
Our wedding at the Beotherhood was everything we dreamed of! It was a flawless space for our vendors to create the most amazing wedding. Donnie was so accommodating throughout the whole process and our vendors raved about working there! The backdrop was the perfect place to have the wedding of our dreams and their partnerships with frequent vendors made our wedding planning seamless! -
-
Christopher B. Sent on 07/14/2019
Excellent Venue!!!!
My wife and I got married in May at Brotherhood Winery! We spent a lot of time working with Donnie, who was such a pleasure! He was on top of everything, and was there the day of our wedding to make sure everything went accordingly. It was such a perfect day! We truly recommend getting married here, and if not, at least go and enjoy the delicious wine!!!! -
-
![Julianne]()
Julianne Sent on 01/16/2019Wedding of my dreams!
From the first time I saw photos of Brotherhood Winery I said to myself "this is where I will get married"...and yes, that was before I even had the ring!
My husband and I got engaged while on a trip in London in April of 2017 and had Brotherhood booked as our venue by the beginning of May. We went to see it in person once and we were sold. I was not interested in seeing any other venue.
Every single area on the grounds is amazing. From the archway on the grass where the ceremony took place, to the cobble stone patio where the cocktail hour took place, to the Grand Monarque Hall where the reception took place, one was more beautifully detailed than the last. Breathtaking would be an understatement.
Donny, the wedding coordinator, was amazing to work with! He was quick to respond to my phone calls and emails and always had a thorough answer every time we spoke. He helped ease any concerns we had and he made us feel completely comfortable putting our wedding day in his hands.
The night of our wedding he made sure every single thing was running smoothly, and it certainly did. I can confidently say there was not one hiccup during our wedding day, at least none that I was made aware of... which goes to show how great Donny and his staff are!
If you're looking for a rustic, yet glamorous wedding venue, with an amazing coordinator, Brotherhood Winery is definitely your spot!
-
-
![David & Nick]()
David N. Sent on 10/12/2018We got married 2 weeks ago today. And to be honest, I could write in here all day about how amazing our experience was. We came out to the venue one day for a wine tasting at the recommendation of family and just fell In love with how cool a space it is. The venue is really old and has been beautifully restored after a fire. If rustic with modern conveniences(and really good wine) is what you’re after, this is the place. But the actual wedding space aside, it’s really the people that makes the difference. Donny and his staff at the Brotherhood are really top notch. Through out the entire year of planning anything we needed Donny was there to help us. Phone calls and emails were always answered back that same day or the next no matter how small or large a detail we were trying to find out about. The day of the event they all worked together with our amazing caterer(Inn credible caterers see my seperate review) to really put the space together. Everything was seamless, there were no issues to speak of, and our guests had the time of our lives. We heard from most of the guests our wedding was one of if not the best they had been to. We also setup a private wine tasting and tour for our guests the day before to really start the weekend off and that was a lot of fun for everybody as well. The Beotherhood is one half of the wedding dream team, and you won’t be disappointed unless you go someplace else. -
Celestina Sent on 10/04/2018Brotherhood Winery was just the absolute perfect venue for my husband and me. The second we took a look at the grounds and the Grand Monarque Hall, we booked the venue the next day. I cannot say enough about how amazing Donny was to work with and all of the recommendations he gave us for vendors. From the countless emails and calls to working with us on the timeline to recommending Inn Credible Caterers to us, we had such an amazing experience and are so grateful to their team for pulling off our dream wedding, they truly surpassed our expectations! All of his communication was so timely and detailed, I was always amazed at how quickly Donny got back to us and was so flexible with our needs. We had our ceremony on site by the mansion and we could not have asked for a more beautiful backdrop. The way the room was set up, to the unbelievable food (Inn Credible caterers), to the friendly staff and the event coordinator's assistance throughout, and the seamless flow of the evening, everything was done to perfection! We couldn’t be happier with our experience, we can’t thank Brotherhood and Inn Credible caterers wonderful staff enough for making our vision a reality!!!
-
-
Jessica Sent on 07/23/2018We feel so lucky to have had our wedding at Brotherhood Winery. The setting is absolutely stunning! Donny and his team were great to work with!
-
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message