Paula and Simon have provided us with a beautiful wedding cake with a touch of home-style love and cooking. We, along with our guests, really enjoyed the layered cake we had made with Paula. She was fantastic in being flexible, organized, free-flowing and artistic with her beauty and taste of what should be a perfect wedding cake. We would like to make certain to let anyone out there know to support Paula & Simon's CakeFiction! 5-stars all the way through with the kindness and aforementioned qualities.

Bhavesh, Wedding Date: 06/03/2017


Wedding cake, groom's cakes, engagement cakes, cupcake displays and favors by internationally trained pastry chef Paula Tosonotti. Call to book a tasting at our fabulous boutique cakery in a converted historic New Jersey barn.


Cake & Bakery - Frequently Asked Questions
What types of desserts do you provide?
Cakes, Cookies, Croquembouche, Cupcakes, Groom's Cake
What services do you provide?
Consultations, Custom Cake Design, Delivery, Setup, Tastings - Private
What cake items do you provide?
Cake Stands
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
Gluten Free, Kosher, Nut Free, Vegan
What special ingredients do you use?
Fresh Fruit, Local, Organic
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Business Info
What types of events do you service?
Anniversaries, Baby Showers, Bar / Bat Mitzvahs, Birthdays, Bridal Showers, Christenings, Corporate Events, Debutante Balls, Eco-Friendly / Green Weddings, Engagement Parties, Graduations, Holiday Parties, LGBTQ Weddings / Ceremonies, Memorials, Proms, Quinceaneras, Sweet 16s

45 Reviews

Samantha, Wedding Date: 09/16/2017
Quality of Service: 5.0 Responsiveness: 5.0 Professionalism: 5.0 Value: 5.0 Flexibility: 5.0

My husband and I worked with Paula and Simon of Cake Fiction for our wedding cake. It was one of the easiest decisions we made in planning our wedding-- they went over all of the options with us, sketched a perfect design and even went out of their way to bake extra cupcakes so we could share the tasting experience with our families. The cake was absolutely beautiful, and their interpretation of our design was more than we could have ever asked for. Our guests continue to talk about how delicious the cake was -- and we never thought we would say this, but it was so good that we actually cant wait to dig into our topper on our first anniversary! Can't wait to work with them again in the future!

Services Used: Cake & Bakery

Catherine, Wedding Date: 08/05/2017
Quality of Service: 5.0 Responsiveness: 5.0 Professionalism: 5.0 Value: 5.0 Flexibility: 5.0

Paula provided my daughter's wedding with a beautiful cake that tasted delicious. I've had many wedding cakes that tasted strange or artificial, but Paula uses all natural quality ingredients that result in a delicious cake. Our guests complimented us on the cake. Cake Fiction has many styles and flavors to choose from to create a unique wedding cake. We chose pound cake with raspberry mousse and lemon curd fillings. Yum! We wish we had an extra slice right now. We would definitely use Paula and Cake Fiction again. She is an artist too in the cake's design. It was lovely.

Services Used: Cake & Bakery

Jennifer, Wedding Date: 07/22/2017
Quality of Service: 5.0 Responsiveness: 5.0 Professionalism: 4.5 Value: 5.0 Flexibility: 5.0

We went to cake tastings at two bakeries, and the cake from Cake Fiction blew the other cake away. Everything tasted very fresh and homemade. We got so many compliments on our cake during and after our wedding!

Services Used: Cake & Bakery

Dom, Wedding Date: 06/16/2017
Quality of Service: 5.0 Responsiveness: 5.0 Professionalism: 5.0 Value: 5.0 Flexibility: 5.0

Paula and Simon did a fantastic job with wedding cake. They were very helpful as to guidance with the design. Their cake and icing flavors are so unique and interesting that your guests will be wowed. They are genuine folks who just wish to provide an excellent service and products. They are successful on both points. We will definitely use their company in the future.

Services Used: Cake & Bakery