Mike's Amazing Cakes Reviews
Reviews
4.6 out of 5 rating
4.6 out of 5 rating
114 Reviews
93% recommend it
Awards
-
![Katie]()
Katie F. Sent on 02/05/2023Professional and Wonderful
Mike and his team contributed to making our wedding magical. His cakes are masterpieces and even though we wanted a simple cake, he treated our wedding with the same professionalism and attention to detail. Thank you! -
-
![Ann]()
Ann M. Sent on 09/20/2022Perfection.
I used to make wedding cakes a long time ago, and have since let that go to pursue a different path in life, so I know a good cake when I see (and taste) one. While my husband said that Mike was a little gruff on the phone, I feel that Mike was a very nice straight forward, no frills kind of guy. Husband was in charge of this vendor at first but I ended up taking over to make sure things were just right :) Mike delivered everything on time, made everything perfectly, was very affordable in my opinion, and was totally cool with us changing our design and flavors up to 10 days prior to the day if we wanted. His cake flavor offerings are delicious, and his buttercream frosting melts in your mouth. Despite the airy texture of the cake frosting, it held up so well in our summer forest wedding (it was in a room that didn't have the best AC). Thanks Mike, we look forward to buying cupcake versions of the cake flavors we chose since everyone gobbled up the cake and we had none left for the two of us after the wedding!!! -
-
Care Sent on 08/28/2020
Mike's Amazing Cakes are truly AMAZING!!
Mike's Amazing Cakes are truly amazing in design and taste! So far we have ordered two cakes and both were made with quality ingredients and great attention to detail. The first was a 10" printed cake for my husband's 30th birthday. He is car guy so we surprised him with a picture of him driving his car printed on the cake. Theresa was very responsive to my emails to finalize the details of the design. I requested a banner on the cake and the end result perfectly matched the aesthetics! At the birthday party, everyone enjoyed and complimented the double chocolate cake.
The second order from Mike's was our wedding cake. Originally we planned a 3-tier cake made with white pleated buttercream with marble cake and chocolate filling. At our appointment, Theresa was very helpful with determining the size of cake we needed to match our guest count. However, once the pandemic hit, which changed with our wedding plans, Mike's was willing to modify our order to a 6" single tier 4.5" tall cake for our wedding photo session. He called a week in advance to confirm our order and was very fast to answer questions I had by email. Pick up was easy and the cake held it's shape in the warm weather outside for a couple of hours. But just as important, it tasted AMAZING!! -
-
Lyssa C. Sent on 07/11/2019
So pretty!
Our cake was beautiful and so delicious! I was able to provide a couple of pinterest photos and they absolutely nailed our design. There are so many cake/frosting flavors to choose from and ours tasted so good. Everything was delivered on time and looked amazing. I cant wait to cut into our last piece on our anniversary! -
-
![Nikaela]()
Nikaela Sent on 12/27/2018Beautiful, actually delicious cake
While we didn't really get a chance to eat our cake besides when we cut it, we've heard nothing but rave reviews from some pretty harsh critics. They offer beautiful sample cakes for cheap and we got to choose two different flavor combos to suit our own personalities, plus the design was stunning! We went with a simpler, all-white cake with cable-knit details to fit our Christmas wedding. It definitely stood out surrounded by all the red and plaid! Most importantly, we had some cake connoisseurs in the crowd who said it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had!! We will definitely use them again for future cake needs. -
![Delilah]()
Delilah Sent on 07/19/2018The cake they made for us was out of this world! Mike went above and beyond what we wanted with our cake. And the cake topper was so inventive and creative and perfectly fit my and my husband's personalities. We cannot thank them enough. I highly recommend going with Mike's Amazing Cakes for any of your deserts. -
-
![Barbara]()
Barbara Sent on 07/20/2018Mike's Amazing Cakes is fantastic! Our cake looked exactly like we wanted it to, and had all the amazing pieces we could have asked for. It was very reasonably priced, and tasted GREAT! I can't wait to have the top next year when we celebrate our 1 year. I cannot recommend Mike's Amazing Cakes enough! -
-
Kaitlyn Sent on 03/10/2018Mike's Amazing Cakes did such a great job on our wedding cake! We decided to do two flavors, red velvet with cream cheese frosting on the top and bottom tier and carrot cake with cream cheese frosting for the middle tier. Both flavors were absolutely delicious, but I am a hardcore carrot cake fan so that was my favorite. They made the cake tasting so easy to schedule and were so flexible with our times. Theresa is always available to answer questions by email which I appreciated so much and she explained everything so well and made it so easy. The cake was delivered on time and I definitely appreciate all their hard work and would definitely recommend!
-
-
![Jordan]()
Jordan Sent on 10/23/2017Mike's Amazing Cakes came to the rescue for my wedding. A few weeks before our wedding, the original cake company we were going to go through with told us they didn't feel comfortable doing our wedding cake since we just wanted a very small one for my Groom and I to cut and we were going to offer other desserts to our guests. So I was in quite a bind with figuring out what to do about a wedding cake. I contacted Mike's Amazing Cakes and was able to get exactly what I wanted at an amazing deal and they would even deliver the cake the day of our wedding. I can not thank Mike and his amazing staff (Theresa) for helping me (the stressed out Bride to be) take care of the cake and have it be so simple but to me very elegant and exactly what I wanted. Thank you to everyone at Mike's for being so amazing and helping out a stressful situation! Your customer service is amazing and the cake was to die for! Will definitely be ordering cake from you more often!! I highly recommend them for a wedding cake or even a special events cake! -
-
![Joanna]()
Joanna Sent on 06/26/2016It's been over a month since our wedding day and I'm still thinking about how delicious our cake was. I wish I could've taken home more cake. We've already decided that on our wedding anniversaries, we plan on getting our anniversary cake at Mike's! During our tasting the samples were excellent and our cake tasted even better on the day of the wedding! There are so many flavor combinations to choose from and it was so hard to narrow it down to just our top two. I think I might have to get our birthday cakes here from now on. My mouth is watering as I'm writing this review and thinking about their cakes HAHA. -
User2379731 Sent on 10/20/2015So accommodating and flexible. Plus, the cake is delicious. And incredible value for an unbeatable cake! -
![Jeanette]()
Jeanette Sent on 04/13/2015Not knowing much about wedding cakes, I brought "Mike's" a picture of a cake I found on Pinterest. Not only were they able to recreate this beautiful cake; but they made it better, it tasted amazing, and the people were were friendly and accommodating! -
User2213280 Sent on 07/06/2015The name says it all! The cakes are truly amazing. We found a picture online and wanted our cake to be similar but with a slightly different pattern and colors and it turned out perfectly. The thing that really stood out to us was the taste. We went to one of their tasting events and got to sample a variety of flavors. The marble cake with salted caramel buttercream was delicious and we both agreed that it was the best tasting wedding cake we had ever tasted.
Our cake wasn't all that fancy but they have some seriously cool cakes in their gallery so we're planning on getting another cake for some future special occasion!
Are you interested?
Send a message
Are you interested?
Send a message