Montauk Yacht Club Reviews
Reviews
4.6 out of 5 rating
4.6 out of 5 rating
12 Reviews
92% recommend it
-
Featured
![Caitlin]()
Caitlin P. Sent on 09/03/2023Montauk Yacht Club - the BEST!
My husband and I signed for this venue very early in 2021 for a May 2023 wedding because we loved the beautiful ballroom, the lighthouse, and the views of lake Montauk. There is a sophisticated beachy Montauk vibe in this space which was exactly what we were searching for! A hidden gem of a venue in Montauk. It also gave us the waterfront vibe we were searching for. Signing 2 years in advance was simply because we LOVED the venue and knew this was the place we wanted to say “I do”. Now the venue did change hands during that time, but Kyle and later Britany were there every step of the way assuring us that our day would be perfect. The new owners also updated the space which was awesome as it gave the property the facelift it needed in time for our big day. Kyle remained on staff under the new owners and was there to answer our many emails and guide us through the transition and when Britany & the rest of the team joined they helped us plan the remaining steps and were very hands on day of to ensure it went seamlessly! Kyle was there handing us champagne & steaming my husband’s jacket before the ceremony – so supportive through the entire process! We used space upstairs in the lighthouse to get ready the day of on property which saved the headache of having to travel around - everyone was coming to us! The kitchen was able to accommodate the groom’s severe nut allergy which gave us the peace of mind to enjoy our big day and he could eat freely and have no worries about that being a factor. The food options were awesome as well! We loved the mini lobster rolls for cocktail hour – when in Montauk right?! Even though we had a VERY rainy day, Montauk Yacht Club staff set up an amazing ceremony in the ballroom by their exquisite fireplace which was a stunning focal point and was so intimate! They have the capacity to seamlessly pivot if the weather doesn’t cooperate and that’s exactly what they did for us! The property is stunning so if you do get to enjoy the outdoor patio for cocktail hour, you’ll have incredible views of lake Montauk! So many options for photos – by the lighthouse, down by the docks, on the roof deck, on the private beach… it’s a stunning property and you don’t have to leave to take photos elsewhere! We also had our afterparty upstairs in the lighthouse room which was perfect for guests. No one needed to travel in the dark or try to get cabs on a rainy day! The after-party food was what you’d dream of – mini hamburgers, grilled cheese, chicken fingers, pizza and fries – need we say more? We also love that Montauk Yacht Club functions as a resort and restaurant! We’ve already been back to dine at Showfish, the restaurant open during the season, and we’re excited for future anniversaries where we can return to celebrate! Truly a lovely day – and we can’t recommend the space & staff more (especially Kyle)! You will be in great hands. -
-
Jessica Sent on 10/01/2018My wedding was phenomenal!! Gurney's Montauk Yacht Club is an absolutely stunning venue and hotel. The Farmhouse Ballroom is so gorgeous! My guests absolutely loved the indoor/outdoor feel with the bar outside and the dancing and tables inside. I was supposed to get married outside but it was a really windy day. Getting married in the farmhouse ballroom blew my mind away, though! You can't go wrong with any of the ceremony/cocktail hour locations. The venue completely fulfilled (and exceeded my expectations)! Bretlin worked with me every step of the way as I made a ton of changes, Kaitlyn answered everyone of my million questions, and Denice did a wonderful job arranging everything the day of. Donovan was an amazing banquet coordinator and the wait staff was so nice and so attentive. The drinks were strong, the food was great and the wedding day went super smooth. I could not have asked for a better day!
-
-
![Stefanie]()
Stefanie Sent on 07/20/2015We had our Rehearsal Dinner at the Montauk Yacht Club and stayed here for our wedding weekend and it was perfect. Everyone we encountered and worked with were helpful and friendly and the dinner was amazing! We had the Italian buffet with an open bar and it was perfect, our guests really enjoyed the food.
The event was held in their Vanderbilt Room on the second floor and had a private balcony which everyone enjoyed taking pictures on and looking out onto the beautiful property.
We highly recommend the Montauk Yacht Club for your event in Montauk!
Love, Stefanie and Daniel Valenti -
User1372380 Sent on 10/09/2013When looking for a wedding venue my (now) husband and I had a lot of criteria to be met. The Montauk Yacht Club offered everything we were looking for and more. It goes without saying that the setting is gorgeous but what you may not know just from a visit is how wonderful Michelle, Amanda, and the rest of the catering staff at MYC are to work with.
They were great about communicating and making sure we were happy throughout the whole planning process. The entire staff at the MYC is so detail oriented and just what a bride and groom need to put their minds at ease. When it came time to the actual wedding day they truly made sure our day was seamless and perfect. -
User993322 Sent on 10/28/2012I wish I could give MTK Yacht Club a better review because the venue itself is beautiful. When I first signed up for my wedding I was made to feel that I should be lucky that I'm being allowed to have my wedding there. It ended up getting a bit better after having a call that ended with me in tears.
I had a wedding planner on-site which is an ABSOLUTE must if you are having your wedding here as the staff is just not able to handle. Long and short... the venue is gorgeous. I do recommend having your wedding there however I do recommend that you have a wedding planner or at lease someone on-site the day-of to assist.
Are you interested?
Send a message